in

Gotham FC’s title defense comes to crushing end in semifinal loss after venue change

gotham-fc’s-title-defense-comes-to-crushing-end-in-semifinal-loss-after-venue-change
Gotham FC’s title defense comes to crushing end in semifinal loss after venue change

See more of our coverage in your search results.

They came by car, by the special-event X80 bus, by bike if they were feeling sporty.

They came in layers, in beanies and scarves, with Gotham’s black-and-sky-blue colors on top.

They came on behalf of those who couldn’t come, capacity being reduced at this impromptu change of venue, each one trying to make noise for five.

Gotham FC forward Sam Kerr competes for the ball against Kansas City Current defender Gabrielle Robinson during a match.

Gotham FC forward Sam Kerr (20) competes for the ball against Kansas City Current defender Gabrielle Robinson (24) on Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026, in New York City. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

They came with some measure of outrage — these home-field shenanigans would never happen in men’s sports — while their better angels told them to come in joy, in celebration, everyone watching women’s sports.

And then, 25 miles and 20,000 seats removed from their regular destination at New Jersey’s Sports Illustrated Stadium, huddled in the bleachers by a blue track ringing an immaculate pitch at Icahn Stadium on Randall’s Island, in the shadow of the old Psychiatric Center and with the light fading over the Costco across the river, 5,000 devoted souls Sunday afternoon watched Gotham’s NWSL title defense end in a 2-1 semifinal loss to the Kansas City Current.

“We lost today because we weren’t the better team,” Gotham winger and oracle Midge Purce said. “That being said, I would say it’s inexcusable. It’s not what you want in a professional league. It’s not what you want for women who are progressing in the United States and supposed to be one of the best leagues in the entire world. I think it’s a bad look for everyone involved. And we always want to be at Sports Illustrated in front of our fans when we earned that right throughout the season. But I would say it had no effect on performance today.”

The match had been moved to Icahn on Monday due to concerns over the disintegrating field conditions at Sports Illustrated, which had unfortunately overshadowed Gotham’s quarterfinal victory there last weekend. Gotham was unbeaten in its past 13 matches at Sports Illustrated, which is operated by the Red Bulls of MLS.

Croix Bethune celebrates scoring a goal with Kansas City Current teammate Lo'eau LaBonta.

Croix Bethune, left, celebrates scoring a goal with Kansas City Current teammate Lo’eau LaBonta during an NWSL playoff match in New York, Nov. 15, 2026. Getty Images

“I think that’s also part of the sadness,” head coach Juan Carlos Amorós said. “I think we never know what would have happened if we played on a good pitch. I think it was the right decision to come here. I think the pitch in the other stadium was unfortunately unplayable.”

Tickets for the semifinal were reallotted and grabbed up in a hurry, while Gotham officials ground on the logistics of moving their game-day operations.

“Obviously not ideal we had to change stadiums, but … I think that’s really awesome to come into a new environment, a new stadium, you have to adapt, you have to make sure you can bring that energy and our supporters did that tonight and that’s incredible,” Gotham midfielder Savannah McCaskill said.

NJ/NY Gotham FC fans hold a sign reading

Fans of NJ/NY Gotham FC hold a sign before an NWSL playoff semifinal match at Icahn Stadium in New York on Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026. Getty Images

But silence descended on these soccer pilgrims when Haley Hopkins scored off a Kansas City set piece in the 89th minute.

Gotham had tied the game in the 69th minute when Purce’s teasing ball was turned in for an own goal. That canceled out Croix Bethune’s curling free-kick score in the 15th minute.

Though appearing more dangerous following the introduction of banged-up midfield star Rose Lavelle at halftime, Gotham finished with zero shots on target and just 0.49 expected goals, per FotMob.

It was a crushing end to what in some ways was the franchise’s most successful campaign — competing in the FIFA Women’s Champions Cup in London in January, claiming the in-season Challenge Cup, selling out Citi Field for a July spectacle and then winning its first NWSL Shield by finishing atop the standings.

Gotham FC forward Guro Reiten tries to gain control of the ball against Kansas City Current defender Laney Rouse.

Gotham FC forward Guro Reiten (18) tries to gain control of the ball against Kansas City Current defender Laney Rouse (2) on Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026, in New York. IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

“Gotham has raised the bar around the league and in our country,” said Kansas City coach Chris Armas, whose club got revenge for last season’s home playoff loss to Gotham.

The playoffs give — as they had in Gotham’s long-shot runs to the crown in 2023 and 2025 — and they painfully take away.

“We didn’t get to win all three trophies that we want to this year, but it’s a positive thing to see how far we’ve come throughout the season,” McCaskill said.

Amorós said: “With perspective, it’s a good season.”

Leave a Reply

rams-star-aaron-donald-reminds-nfl-he’s-still-a-problem-1,050-days-later

Rams star Aaron Donald reminds NFL he’s still a problem 1,050 days later

wyndham-clark-proposes-to-emily-tanner-during-romantic-outdoor-getaway

Wyndham Clark proposes to Emily Tanner during romantic outdoor getaway