A man I worked with came into a therapy session upset about a woman he’d met on Hinge. They’d been messaging for weeks and seemed to have a lot in common. They went to the same college, rooted for the same sports teams, and liked the same foods. They’d made plans to meet, and he was looking forward to it.
Then, just before meeting, she asked, “You’re not a Trumper, are you?”
He told her he was a moderate and didn’t have strong political views. She wasn’t satisfied. She accused him of being a “privileged white male” who could afford not to take a stand. When he questioned her reaction, she told him only women and minorities could understand. And just like that, the relationship was over before they’d even met.
I’ve seen similar situations in my practice and encountered them in my own life. Politics has become something people want to know about a potential partner almost immediately. You can have plenty in common, find each other attractive, and want the same things out of life, but the wrong political affiliation can end things before they start. Political compatibility matters. But somewhere along the way, asking about someone’s values turned into demanding proof of political loyalty.
Look through dating profiles, and you’ll find declarations like “Swipe left if you’re MAGA,” “No Trump supporters,” or “If you voted for Trump, we’re not a match.” People are ruling each other out without ever talking.
An April 2025 NPR/PBS News/Marist poll found that 60% of Americans ages 18 to 29 consider it important to date or marry someone who shares their political views. Among adults 60 and older, the figure was 35%.
I understand why politics matters. I’ve seen couples fight repeatedly over abortion, religion, or how they wanted to raise their children. These aren’t minor differences. Sometimes they become reasons to separate. That’s why I believe politics should come up early in dating, especially if someone wants to get married and have children. Why spend a year getting attached to someone only to discover that you have completely different ideas about the family you want?
But that’s not what happened with my patient. The woman didn’t ask what he believed about marriage, children, religion, or any specific issue. She wanted to know whether he supported Trump. When he said he was a moderate, she decided that told her enough. He wasn’t defending Trump. He wasn’t particularly interested in politics at all. But apparently that wasn’t good enough. His reluctance to take a side became evidence of privilege.
There’s nothing wrong with ruling someone out over politics. But this woman didn’t even know what my patient believed. She heard the word “moderate” and decided that was enough. I don’t know whether she considered herself open-minded, but she wasn’t willing to meet someone who wouldn’t take her side politically.
We’ve seen similar divisions in families and friendships, where people stop speaking over elections. Now they’re bringing that same attitude to dating.
I find it strange that people think they can judge someone’s character by a vote. I’ve known Republicans who are liberal on social issues and Democrats who are traditional about marriage and family. People vote based on all sorts of reasons. You might learn something about a person from their politics, but you still don’t know whether they’d make a good husband or wife.
Another problem is treating politics as a dating checklist. I’ve worked with people who met someone who seemed perfect for them. They had similar backgrounds, successful careers, shared goals, and even the same politics. Everything looked right on paper, but the attraction wasn’t there. Some stayed in these relationships because they thought they should be happy. The person checked every box. Their friends approved. But none of that created romantic feelings.
Political compatibility is no different. Two people can agree on every election and still be miserable together. That doesn’t mean chemistry should outweigh major differences in values. If two people disagree about religion, abortion, marriage, or raising children, they may have no business getting married. But those disagreements need to be understood, not guessed at from a party label.
Some qualities that matter enormously in a marriage have little to do with politics. Is someone honest? Faithful? Dependable? Can they handle disagreements without becoming nasty? Will they stand by you when things get difficult? Sharing the same politics doesn’t guarantee any of that.
My patient and the woman might have been completely incompatible. Maybe they would have met for a drink and discovered they had very different ideas about life. But they’ll never know. He wasn’t rejected because of something he believed. He was rejected because he wouldn’t declare allegiance to a political camp. When even moderation becomes a dating dealbreaker, politics has begun to determine not just how we vote, but whom we’re willing to know.
***
Jonathan Alpert is a psychotherapist in New York City and Washington, D.C., and author of the book “Therapy Nation.” Find him on X @JonathanAlpert.


