in

New Yorkers will lose discounts if ‘poorly written’ surveillance pricing bills become law: business group

new-yorkers-will-lose-discounts-if-‘poorly-written’-surveillance-pricing-bills-become-law:-business-group
New Yorkers will lose discounts if ‘poorly written’ surveillance pricing bills become law: business group

See more of our coverage in your search results.

New Yorkers will lose some discounts at check-out if new city and state legislation meant to rein in onerous “surveillance pricing” schemes by big companies are signed into law, an influential business group claims in a new ad campaign.

The New York State Business Council urged Big Apple Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Gov. Kathy Hochul to veto the newly passed bills that aim to stop companies from using algorithms to set prices for individual users based on their personal data.

“These bills are so poorly written, so poorly vetted, and so poorly understood that most folks don’t know that they will cause every single New York family to lose discounts that they rely on to save money,” Business Council President Paul Zuber told The Post.

Illustration of three smartphone screens from an anti-Mamdani advertisement warning against surveillance pricing legislation.
New York business groups warn against surveillance pricing legislation in an anti-Mamdani advertisement. Coalition for an Affordable NY

“The Business Council is starting a statewide campaign so consumers understand what is about to happen to the very popular discounts that we all know and love,” Zuber said.

The major statewide lobbying group’s campaign will include ads plastered online and on TV, as well as a splashy website complete with an interactive game where users try to fill a shopping cart as an evil-looking cartoon of City Hall steals their discounts.

The Albany-based organization claims that banning price-setting based on users’ personal data could restrict loyalty rewards, travel discounts and some promotions like birthday coupons.

The “One Fair Price Act” was passed by the state Legislature in June at the urging of New York Attorney General Letitia James — who said it was “wrong” for companies to use people’s internet browsing data and other personal information to set prices. 

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani speaks at a press conference about winter weather plans.
NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani has signaled support for city councils legislation, which has been fought by companies like Uber. James Messerschmidt for NY Post

“The price still isn’t right,” James spokesperson Alexis Richards sniped to The Post Tuesday, referencing its Dec. 10, 2025, cover story on a study showing Instacart used artificial intelligence to skew prices for different customers in the same stores.

“The Business Council may have forgotten, but we haven’t,” the AG’s spokesperson added.

While Hochul has declined to weigh in on the state legislation, Mamdani has signaled support of a similar bill in the City Council, sponsored by Speaker Julie Menin.

Start your day with all you need to know

Morning Report delivers the latest news, videos, photos and more.

Thanks for signing up!

“Some companies use your personal data, like browsing history, to serve different prices to different customers. It’s called surveillance pricing, and we just banned it in New York City,” Mamdani posted on X after the council’s passage of its bill last week.

Menin spokesperson Jack Lobel denied the business group’s claims that the legislation would impact discounts.

“Much like surveillance pricing, this campaign uses technology to deceive consumers about the prices they’re paying,” Lobel said in a statement.

“Here’s the truth: Our surveillance pricing ban fully protects legitimate discounts, and corporations are pouring money into opposing the legislation because they’re scared it will hurt their profits,” he said.

Mamdani has until mid-December to sign the legislation, or it will go into effect automatically, and Hochul needs to act before the end of the year.

Leave a Reply

Breaking: US Army Lt. Col. Arrested Over Russian Espionage Suspicions, Transferred to American Custody

nypd-cop-details-heart-pounding-rescue-of-pregnant-woman-at-brooklyn-building-collapse:-‘we-heard-this-woman’s-voice’

NYPD cop details heart-pounding rescue of pregnant woman at Brooklyn building collapse: ‘We heard this woman’s voice’