in

Tyler Robinson defense wants to pause bullet fragment testing in Charlie Kirk assassination

tyler-robinson-defense-wants-to-pause-bullet-fragment-testing-in-charlie-kirk-assassination
Tyler Robinson defense wants to pause bullet fragment testing in Charlie Kirk assassination

Attorneys for Charlie Kirk’s accused assassin Tyler Robinson are asking a Utah judge to put additional ballistics testing on pause as prosecutors attempt to conclusively link bullet fragments recovered at autopsy to the suspected murder weapon, which some experts call unnecessary and even prosecutors admit isn’t central to their case.

The Utah County Attorney’s Office has asked the judge to deny the motion, countering that the testing they are seeking will not consume the evidence or prevent Robinson’s experts from having a look at it once the government is done — and that they have more compelling evidence to introduce at trial.

“There is no reason to believe the bullet fragments contain exculpatory evidence,” Deputy Utah County Attorney Ryan McBride alleged in an opposition to the defense motion.

“To the contrary, all the evidence points to the inculpatory value of the fragments.”

Robinson has allegedly admitted to the shooting, he wrote. Three unspent cartridges in the rifle were consistent with the gunshot fired at Kirk.

Tyler Robinson, accused of aggravated murder, appears during a court hearing in Provo, Utah.

Tyler Robinson appears during a court hearing in Provo, Utah, on Dec. 11, 2025. Getty Images

Charlie Kirk speaks at Utah Valley University in Orem, Utah.

Charlie Kirk speaks at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10, 2025, in Orem, Utah. Kirk was later shot and killed during the event. Getty Images

A computer screen displays evidence of bullet fragments with labels and a scale ruler.

Bullet fragments appear on a screen during a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson at the Fourth District Courthouse in Provo, Utah, on July 9, 2026. AP Photo/Spenser Heaps

The bullet fragments were consistent with the suspected murder weapon, although they have not been conclusively identified to it. And police recovered video evidence and a Dremel tool consistent with etchings made on brass casings recovered in the rifle at the scene.

While the fragment testing, known as virtual comparison microscopy (VCM), won’t destroy the evidence, it is expected to physically alter or even damage it, according to court filings.

“Petals” from the fragments may be folded out of the way as investigators look for rifling markings on the underlying surface, according to prosecutors.

Start your day with all you need to know

Morning Report delivers the latest news, videos, photos and more.

Thanks for signing up!

The fragments may be cleaned, at least in a small area. And lead fragments may be cleaned or scraped. There is a risk that pieces break off during the process.

Robinson’s lawyers want the VCM testing placed on hold until they have a chance to examine and photograph the same evidence — or an order allowing a defense expert to observe the testing in person or via a video recording, something the FBI does not allow for a number of reasons, including contamination and national security concerns.

They argued that prior ATF testing already damaged the evidence, and the next round of testing could result in further harm.

Tyler Robinson with defense attorneys Kathryn Nester and Staci Visser during a court hearing.

Kathryn Nester, left, Tyler Robinson, center, and Staci Visser appear in court on Dec. 11, 2025, in Provo, Utah. Getty Images

“The ATF couldn’t conclusively connect the bullet fragment to the recovered rifle, but it couldn’t rule out the rifle either,” said Jason Pack, a retired FBI supervisory agent who has been following the case. “That’s an important distinction, and it helps explain why prosecutors want the FBI to take another look.”

He explained that VCM is a more advanced process than simply looking at the fragments under a microscope, a more traditional method. Even so, there’s no guarantee that examiners will find a more conclusive link between the fragments and the suspected murder weapon.

“If the markings are too damaged or simply aren’t there anymore, even the best technology can’t bring them back,” Pack told Fox News Digital.

A bullet casing engraved with

A bullet casing engraved with “Hey Fascist!” is displayed during a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson in Provo, Utah, on July 9, 2026. AP Photo/Spenser Heaps

Robinson is accused of shooting Kirk at Utah Valley University during a Turning Point USA public speaking event on Sept. 10, 2025. During Kirk’s autopsy, investigators recovered a bullet jacket fragment and four lead fragments from his body, according to prosecutors.

“If the bullet fragment is again altered to the point where no independent comparison is possible, then the degree of prejudice to the defendant is severe,” Robinson’s lawyers wrote to the court. “The defense will be unable to independently verify conclusions, cross-examination will be unfairly limited, and the jury will hear unchallengeable expert testimony.”

Bernard Zapor, a former ATF special agent in charge and faculty associate at Arizona State University, said those concerns may be overblown.

Fourth District Court Judge Tony Graf speaks during a hearing.

Fourth District Court Judge Tony Graf speaks during a hearing for Tyler Robinson in Provo, Utah, on June 12, 2026. Getty Images

The fragments were already documented meticulously during the ATF’s initial examination, he said, with photographs, data and images available to the defense through discovery.

If the fragments are damaged during additional testing, it may not change much, since the initial testing was inconclusive — which he said is not unusual in shootings involving similar caliber weapons.

“This is all distracting from the purpose of getting information to the jury so they can come to a conclusion, one way or the other,” he told Fox News Digital. “This case is solid. You don’t want to do anything to disrupt it.”

People run after shots were fired during an appearance by Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University.

People are pictured running after shots were fired during an appearance by Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University in Orem, Utah, on Sept. 10, 2025. Getty Images

Robinson’s lawyers previously flagged in court that they intend to challenge the ATF’s findings and methodology.

During prior testing, ATF examiner Samantha Karner cleaned the jacket fragment, photographed it and then peeled the “petals” back to examine groove impressions on it.

She identified the fragment as having been in the .30 caliber class, but she was unable to conclusively link it to the suspected murder weapon, Robinson’s grandfather’s .30-06 Mauser rifle.

“Given the limited detail that Ms. Karner observed, she could not include or exclude the fragment as having been fired from the recovered rifle,” prosecutors wrote.

A casing engraved with the words

A casing engraved with the words “TEST SHOT” is displayed during a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson in Provo, Utah, on July 9, 2026. AP Photo/Spenser Heaps

“She testified that there was ‘no further testing that [she] could do’ to try to reach a conclusive result … However, she noted ‘the possibility of using a 3D system to visualize the individual characteristics on the bullet,’ to obtain more conclusive results.”

For that kind of analysis, however, the fragments would need to be sent to the FBI for VCM.

“This analysis is non-destructive and uses 3D technology to capture multiple scans of the object,” prosecutors wrote. “The scan data will be preserved and provided to the defense for their own analysis.”

In order to perform the scans, however, analysts may have to clean the fragments or fold back warped metal, called “petals,” to expose the surface of the fragment that contacted the rifle when fired, prosecutors wrote.

Journalists gather as Charlie Kirk's parents exit after a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson.

Journalists gather as Charlie Kirk’s parents exit after a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson in Provo, Utah, on July 9, 2026. AP Photo/Spenser Heaps

Prosecutors are also seeking another type of testing, known as metallurgical testing, on the bullet jacket fragment and at least one piece of lead, according to court filings. That testing might require cleaning “around a small area,” prosecutors added, before it is examined with an X-ray.

“The FBI is also proposing separate testing to compare the metal in the recovered bullet fragments with ammunition seized during the investigation,” Pack said.

“That could provide additional information, although it wouldn’t conclusively identify the firearm.”

Lastly, prosecutors want an examiner to disassemble one of the unfired .30-06 cartridges found at Robinson’s home after his arrest, for comparison.

Robinson’s attorneys entered not guilty pleas on his behalf to all charges. He could face the potential death penalty if convicted of the top count of aggravated murder.

Leave a Reply

markwayne-mullin-furiously-defends-gov’t-flight-to-lsu-texas-game-after-faa-ground-stop,-accuses-dems-of-‘hypocrisy’

Markwayne Mullin furiously defends gov’t flight to LSU-Texas game after FAA ground stop, accuses Dems of ‘hypocrisy’

nj-dad-admits-fatally-shooting-stepdaughter’s-french-bulldog-in-the-face-first-time-he-dog-sat

NJ dad admits fatally shooting stepdaughter’s French bulldog in the face first time he dog-sat