in

Lame-Duck Republican Senator Wants To Hand The Left A Massive Legal Victory Before January

lame-duck-republican-senator-wants-to-hand-the-left-a-massive-legal-victory-before-january
Lame-Duck Republican Senator Wants To Hand The Left A Massive Legal Victory Before January

Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) is taking a victory lap on his way out the door. Rather than use his waning days to boost the conservative cause, Senator Tillis spent the lead-up to the midterms promoting his new book, “How to Lose Friends and Antagonize Presidents,” while welcoming the possibility of Republicans in Congress losing their majority. Much of his press tour has been dedicated to attacking President Trump and the Cabinet officials he voted to confirm. In his book, he predicted an “electoral bloodbath,” suggesting that his Republican colleagues should “take the loss and learn something.” Following the election, Tillis has doubled down on blaming President Trump for Republican losses and criticizing War Secretary Pete Hegseth.

This, of course, isn’t Tillis’s first time bashing the president and his own party, but his rhetoric is only the beginning. Before he leaves office in January, Tillis is pushing for legislation that would do far more lasting damage to Republicans and the conservative movement than anything in his book.

Last year, Tillis introduced the Tackling Predatory Litigation Funding Act, a misleadingly named bill that would slap a punitive 40.8% excise tax on Americans who finance lawsuits, nearly double the corporate rate. Litigation finance firms back lawsuits with an agreement to collect a share of the proceeds if the case succeeds. Tillis came close to passing his bill through last year’s reconciliation package, but ultimately failed. Now, Tillis has made clear he isn’t finished, and he has until January to do it. Tillis has also endorsed similar measures that would force disclosure of the identities of those financially supporting litigation — handing opposing counsel, hostile regulators, and activist attorneys general a list of everyone who helps finance a case.

Senator Tillis sells his bill as a defense against foreign adversaries abusing the American legal system — a concerning problem but one his legislation does nothing to address. I’ve written before about how China bankrolls climate change lawsuits in the United States to undercut American energy dominance. China routes that money through CCP-connected nonprofits and climate advocacy groups via grants and partnerships, not litigation-finance agreements, something these measures miss entirely. Beijing isn’t seeking a financial return on its investment; it benefits when American energy companies are hit with tens of billions of dollars in adverse judgments and are driven towards bankruptcy. If Congress is serious about foreign interference, it can start by investigating these groups.

Most concerning are the meritorious legal fights that Tillis’s bill would impact. The conservative legal movement in recent years has turned to litigation finance as a tool to support costly lawsuits against deep-pocketed opponents. Cases have been brought against corporations pushing harmful DEI and ESG mandates, the big banks that have debanked conservatives and religious groups, doctors who performed transgender surgeries on children, and other well-funded left-wing institutions, like Planned Parenthood.

Many of these suits pit a single employee, a religious group, or a family-owned business against an opponent that can afford to litigate for years. Few plaintiffs can carry those costs on their own. Litigation funders help to cover legal expenses in exchange for a share of any recovery, collecting nothing if the case is lost. Tillis’s punitive tax bill is designed to push these benefactors out of the market and leave plaintiffs with few ways to hold the institutions that wronged them accountable.

It’s no surprise the U.S. Chamber of Commerce is one of the bill’s loudest champions. The Chamber spent recent years defending woke corporations and prioritizing DEI objectives over meritocracy. By starving plaintiffs of the resources they need to get to court, the Chamber hopes those companies can dodge legal accountability for the harmful, out-of-touch policies they’ve forced on employees and American consumers.

Now, with a Democrat-controlled Congress coming, Tillis’s bill would leave conservatives with even fewer resources to fight back. A Democratic majority means more pressure on corporations to adopt DEI and ESG mandates, more left-wing lawfare, and emboldened blue-state attorneys general targeting conservative groups and their speech. Without the resources to fight back, conservatives will lose an important tool to challenge that agenda in court. Worse still, the disclosure mandates Tillis has endorsed would then give those same opponents and left-wing entities a map of those supporting conservative legal organizations and causes.

Tillis claims he wrote his book to save his party from itself. Conservatives should judge him by what he’s still trying to pass. His bill raises taxes on private investment, it weakens the conservative legal movement, and it does nothing to stop China’s lawfare campaign against American industries. Republicans in Congress should reject it, whether Tillis forces a vote before January or someone else picks it up after he’s gone.

 ***

Chad R. Mizelle is the former chief of staff to the attorney general of the United States and former acting general counsel of the Department of Homeland Security.

Leave a Reply

outage-hits-nsa’s-classified-communications-system-for-third-straight-day

Outage Hits NSA’s Classified Communications System For Third Straight Day

ex-student-sues-california-department-of-education-over-hack-that-exposed-millions-of-kids’-addresses-and-disability-records

Ex-student sues California Department of Education over hack that exposed millions of kids’ addresses and disability records