in

My Agent Said I’d Been ‘Coded Right-Wing.’ So I Started My Own Publishing Company.

my-agent-said-i’d-been-‘coded-right-wing’-so-i-started-my-own-publishing-company.
My Agent Said I’d Been ‘Coded Right-Wing.’ So I Started My Own Publishing Company.

I need you to know what a joy it was to be a novelist in the early aughts.

I felt like Philip Roth, cranky and older (I was 39), my work edgy, yet domestic. My advance was a year’s salary. I met my book’s team over lunch in Manhattan. Then there was a flurry of fat overnight packages containing edited paper manuscripts, paper clips rearranging the sections, and penciled notes everywhere.

My debut was in 2005 — maybe the last year of glorious old-school writing tales. I went on to write three more books: a nonfiction title in 2009 and novels in 2012 and 2015. Then I quit writing for years.

There were many reasons, the greatest of which was a personal tragedy in 2016. But also, the publishing world had changed. My last advance was 10% of my first, the editor overworked and uninterested in an exchange of handwritten notes. Also, there was an outsider quality to my work that had served me originally, but it had whipsawed to become a liability.

No one named it until 2023, when I went to my longtime agent with a new project, the first in nearly a decade. A few weeks passed before he called me. But this was nothing like the bright, friendly calls we used to have. 

“I’ve read your pages and they’re wonderful,” he said. “Maybe your best work yet. But I’m sorry, no one will read them. I’m afraid you’ve been coded right-wing.”

It was the first time I’d ever heard the word used that way: coded. This wasn’t personal. To his credit, Esmond (who has since, sadly, died) was not making judgments, only giving me facts. He worked with a ton of authors more conservative than I, but they wrote business books, and that was sanctioned in publishing. Women’s literary fiction, on the other hand? He was as firm as I’d ever heard him. There was zero space for someone like me.

Truth is, I’d always ridden the margin with gritty novels about ordinary people, regret, forgiveness, and the spirit world. Not your typical domestic fiction sell. My first editor admitted that she took me on despite misgivings because she grew up Catholic and my story reignited her faith. 

But by 2023 I’d spoken out against pandemic school closures and lost my contributor status at mainstream publications such as The Washington Post. I was a pariah in the publishing world.

It wasn’t just me, Esmond said. It was also the material itself. I was writing a novel — based on women I’d interviewed for an essay in a dissident publication — from the point of view of a mother whose adult daughter had become estranged from her. That, too, was a “right-wing” move. Giving voice to the mother in this situation, her hurt and outrage, would be seen by the mostly young, female, Ivy League acquiring editors as inflicting harm.

I believed him and put my manuscript aside. 

A partner from Esmond’s agency wrote to tell me of his sudden death in early 2025. She said they’d be back in touch about representation. I was not surprised when none of his colleagues offered to take me on.

It’s impossible to find data on this trend that everyone knows is happening in publishing because when the industry reports on itself today, it finds itself fair. But any reader or academic can attest that what Publishers Weekly hinted at in 2017 was real: Yes, book publishing is too liberal. And it’s grown more so with each passing year.

I posed the question to Grok: Who are the top 10 currently living and working Republican or right-leaning women in literary fiction, including writers, editors, and publishers? The response: There are basically none. 

Then I posted my results on X, along with a screenshot. What about J.K. Rowling and Lionel Shriver? people asked. I responded that they both live and publish overseas (Rowling is a British citizen and Shriver was a dual British-U.S. citizen but lives in Portugal) and both identify as liberals. In fact, Shriver voted for Joe Biden in the 2020 election and did not vote in 2024 because she said both Donald Trump and Kamala Harris were unacceptable.

As for Rowling, she’s a hero. But if she hadn’t published the most beloved children’s series since “The Wizard of Oz” and made the industry billions of dollars before coming out against trans activism, she certainly wouldn’t have a publisher in the West.

Grok did offer results it said represented “centrist” women writers: Marilynne Robinson, Anne Tyler, Elizabeth Strout, and Shriver. Only one of these writers counts. I responded with this: “Marilynne Robinson is religious but politically very left of center (I knew her in Iowa City). Anne Tyler has recently expressed political opinions (all left). Lionel Shriver is centrist but mostly out of the country. Strout, yes.”

In the case of modern women’s literature, “centrist” means center-left. Tyler and Barbara Kingsolver were mentioned as liberal writers who occasionally write sympathetic conservative characters. Does this qualify as diversity, people asked? My answer: Only if we’re fine with eliminating all Jewish writers and filling in with Christian and Muslim writers who occasionally write a likable Jew.

Be aware, I have a stake in this as a writer and as a publisher.

I like to think of myself as a centrist. People on the Left say I’m a right-wing extremist and Trump apologist. Many on the Right will tell you I’m just an incurable affluent white female liberal who’s been kicked to the curb. The truth is that at 60, having recently fled the People’s Republic of Minnesota, I lean slightly conservative.

None of that matters when it comes to books. I want it all. Poignant notes from communists, tales of megalomania, futurism, historical stories, black lives, “queer” lives, allegory, and Islam. Because that’s what literature is supposed to be, a portal into absolutely every place, plane, and idea in the universe. And the ones outside it, too.

That’s what my partners and I envisioned when we started our publishing company: unlimited diversity of thought and magnificent, trenchant stories, delivered serially. Absolutely no ideological requirements. Because reading is not, and never should be, a safe space.

We’re starting with that novel about estrangement that Esmond loved but said he could not sell. I was buoyed by his words and after he died, I finished it, then hired a heterodox editor to polish it up. And we’ve already lined up a second title, whose author has a worldview completely different from mine.

We hope people will read because the work is great, not because of how we vote or what our yard signs say. Because that’s not literature. It’s just the stale, predictable, consensus-driving party line.

***

Ann Bauer is the author of “The Formerly Washed-Up Evie Watts” and co-founder of the publishing platform Storyalīz.

This article is part of Upstream, The Daily Wire’s new home for culture and lifestyle. Real human insight and human stories — from our featured writers to you.

Leave a Reply

jeffries-calling-jerusalem-nyc’s-‘sixth-borough’-resurfaces-as-progressives-swing-against-israel

Jeffries calling Jerusalem NYC’s ‘sixth borough’ resurfaces as progressives swing against Israel

The Right to Self-Defense May Not Save You in 2026 Thanks to These Legal Land Mines