There shouldn’t have been much concern about the San Francisco 49ers after a 2-3 start to the season. They are still one of the best teams in football. It’s not entirely perfect for the 49ers yet, and injuries have a lot to do with that, but don’t believe that San Francisco has lost much.
The 49ers had a dominant first half against the Seattle Seahawks on Thursday night, let the Seahawks back in the game for a bit in the second half but ultimately slammed the door shut and beat their NFC West rival yet again, this time by a score of 36-24.
George Kittle scored twice and Deebo Samuel Sr. scored a long touchdown to lead the win.
In an ideal world San Francisco wouldn’t have let Seattle back in the game, it would be undefeated and be the talk of the NFL. This start hasn’t been ideal but the 49ers are still pretty good.
49ers take early lead
One of the reasons the Seahawks made the somewhat surprising decision to end the Pete Carroll era was they were getting run over by the 49ers the past couple seasons. More went into the decision than that, but being completely uncompetitive against their NFC West rival hung over the franchise. They lost five games, including playoffs, to the 49ers the past two seasons and none of them were competitive.
New Seahawks head coach Mike Macdonald had many of the same problems Thursday night.
The game started OK for the Seahawks. They drove deep into 49ers territory. But then Geno Smith missed badly on a throw that was picked off by safety Malik Mustapha. That was the first sign of distress.
The 49ers were backed up at their own 3-yard line after that interception, but they drove 90 yards. The 49ers settled for a field goal at the end of the drive — execution in the red zone was maybe the only thing San Francisco’s offense or defense didn’t do well Thursday — but the drive was all too familiar. The 49ers were pushing the Seahawks around, as usual.
The first half and the start of the second half went that way. Kittle’s first touchdown gave the 49ers a 23-3 lead. But this 49ers team, which has already blown two fourth-quarter leads this season for losses, had to make things interesting again.
Seahawks get back in it
The 49ers’ offense was moving the ball easily, except in the red zone. The defense was all over the field and hitting everything in blue very hard. It was San Francisco’s special teams that let the Seahawks back in the game.
After the 49ers took what looked like an insurmountable 23-3 lead, Laviska Shenault Jr. took a kickoff 97 yards for a touchdown. It was the second kickoff return for a touchdown in the NFL this season. Then Kenneth Walker III scored and the Seahawks trailed 23-17. Niners running back Jordan Mason suffered a shoulder injury in the first half and played just the first play of the second half, and that affected an offense that has been without Christian McCaffrey all season. San Francisco seemed to be in a bit of trouble.
Smith threw an interception that practically decided the outcome. It was woefully underthrown to DK Metcalf, Renardo Green picked it off and the 49ers were in position to put away the game.
Kittle scored again and the 49ers led 29-17. The Seahawks got a touchdown back and trailed 29-24 with less than two minutes left. They kicked off, having all three timeouts left. But Isaac Guerendo, filling in for Mason, who was filling in for McCaffrey, broke a 76-yard run. Kyle Juszczyk scored with 1:17 left to put the game away.
There was some worry about the 49ers, and having three losses early in the season isn’t great for their hopes of getting a No. 1 seed in the NFC. But Thursday night was more proof that they still own the Seahawks and the NFC West, even if there’s still some room for improvement.
Live45 updates
-
Former MVP shows the 49ers some love postgame
-
Here’s how the Niners iced the game
-
FInal stats
Total yards:
49ers 483, Seahawks 358
Passing yards:
49ers 255, Seahawks 306
Rushing yards:
49ers 228, Seahawks 52
San Francisco
Brock Purdy 18-of-28, 255 yards, 3 TD
Isaac Guerendo 10 carries, 99 yards
Deebo Samuel 3 catches, 102 yards, 1 TD
Seattle
Geno Smith 30-of-52, 312 yards, 1 TD, 2 INT
Kenneth Walker 14 rushes, 32 yards
Tyler Lockett 4 catches, 65 yards, 1 TD
Noah Fant 6 catches, 63 yards
-
The 49ers take over after Seattle turns it over on downs with an incomplete pass on 4th down.
Brock Purdy takes a knee to finish off a 36-24 win for San Francisco.
-
Geno Smith sacked
Seattle gets a first down on 4th-and-10 with a Geno Smith 12-yard pass to Noah Fant.
But two plays later, Smith is sacked by Sam Okuayinonu for a six-yard loss. First sack of the entire game.
-
Touchdown, 49ers
Kyle Juszczyk runs up the middle for a six-yard touchdown run that puts it away for San Francisco. After the extra point, the 49ers have a 36-24 lead with 1:17 remaining.
-
First down and much, much more
The Seahawks do not get the stop they need. Isaac Guerendo breaks off a 76-yard run off right tackle for the 49ers and slides to go down at the Seattle 5-yard line to run out the clock.
-
Seahawks do not attempt an onside kick
The Seahawks don’t try an onside kick, hoping their defense can get the ball back with 1:39 remaining and all three timeouts.
-
Touchdown, Seahawks
Tyler Lockett doesn’t drop this pass. Geno Smith hits him for a nine-yard score on a comeback route in the middle of the end zone.
After the extra point, it’s 29-24 with 1:44 remaining.
-
2-minute warning in Seattle
Tyler Lockett nearly caught a nine-yard pass in the back of the end zone for a touchdown, but could not hold on.
It’s 2nd-and-goal from the nine-yard line for the Seahawks with 1:59 remaining.
-
Seahawks TD negated by penalty
An illegal shift penalty on Kenneth Walker wipes out a 52-yard touchdown pass from Geno Smith to DK Metcalf.
-
Touchdown, 49ers
After two Patrick Taylor Jr. rushes, Brock Purdy hits George Kittle over the middle for a nine-yard touchdown pass.
That’s Kittle’s second touchdown of the night.
San Francisco fails on a 2-point conversion attempt and has a 29–17 lead with 6:20 remaining.
-
Geno Smith interception
Geno Smith is picked off by Renardo Green at the Seahawks’ 35-yard line.
After a 20-yard return, San Francisco takes over on the Seattle 15.
-
NFL says it didn’t have proper camera angle on replay review
Prime Video rules analyst Terry McAulay said that the league did not have the enhanced video angle for Dee Williams’ apparent turnover that the telecast showed.
Did Terry McCauley just say that Amazon Prime has better cameras and equipment than the NFL Officiating HQ ???
— Curtis Allen (@curtis93969) October 11, 2024
McAulay’s quote:
“I spoke with Walt Anderson in the command center in New York. What they’re telling me, they didnt get our enhanced video that we showed the ball touching the finger. What they had was the raw feed from our cameras and it was not clear and obvious to them that it touched the finger.”
-
49ers have 1 timeout with 9:38 remaining
San Francisco calls timeout on 3rd-and-9 from the Seattle 40-yard line. That leaves the 49ers with only one timeout after they lost one on a replay challenge.
-
Seahawks can’t capitalize
Despite getting an apparent break on a replay review, the Seahawks have to punt after a 5-play, 12-yard drive. Seattle couldn’t get another first down after Zach Charbonnet’s nine-yard run on 2nd-and-7 to the Seahawks’ 30-yard line.
-
Questionable replay review
Seattle apparently committed a turnover when punt returner Dee Williams touched the ball before the 49ers downed it. Initially, the call on the field looked like it was San Francisco hitting the Seattle returner before he could catch the ball. But officials agreed the tackler was pushed into the receiver.
The 49ers called for a review of the play, arguing that Seattle touched the ball. Replay seemed to confirm that, but the call was upheld.
-
3rd quarter: 49ers 23, Seahawks 17
What looked like a 49ers rout in the making is now a ballgame as we go to the fourth quarter.
San Francisco has the ball on their 26-yard line on 4th-and-3 after Brock Purdy threw a 7-yard pass to Jauan Jennings. They’ll begin the fourth quarter with a punt.
-
Touchdown, Seahawks
The Seahawks are right back in this. Kenneth Walker finishes off a 13-play, 94-yard drive with a one-yard TD run. With the extra point, the 49ers’ lead is cut to 23-17.
The scoring drive was highlighted by Geno Smith hitting Tyler Lockett for a 37-yard gain.
-
Holding penalty kills 49ers’ next drive
After getting a first down to open their next possession, the 49ers’ drive stalls out, due largely to a holding penalty on Jake Brendal.
On 3rd-and-18, Brock Purdy completed a 15-yard pass to Deebo Samuel. But on 4th-and-3, San Francisco had to punt from the 50 on 4th-and 3
