CLEVELAND — On a night when the Yankees wanted Gerrit Cole to pitch like an ace and pick up an overtaxed and short-handed bullpen, the opposite happened.
But a win’s a win.
Five relievers combined to throw five scoreless innings behind Cole, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. shut up a chorus of “Overrated!” chants by hitting a tiebreaking eighth-inning home run to lift the Yankees to a 3-2 victory against the Guardians in front of 27,154 at Progressive Field on Tuesday night.
“Tremendous,” manager Aaron Boone said. “Everyone really doing their job really well.”
Battling the humidity, Cole wasn’t sharp at the wrong time, given that the Yankees burned through seven relievers Monday in a 10-inning win. There was double-barreled action in the bullpen during the fourth, which Cole escaped unscathed on his 83rd and final pitch.
Making his fourth start after Tommy John surgery and his second straight against Cleveland, Cole tired after allowing two runs on two walks and five hits — all singles, including one that was about a foot from clearing the 19-foot wall in left field — while striking out four.
“At a certain point, I was just so gassed,” Cole said. “It’s just like survival mode.”
But Paul Blackburn, Tim Hill, Camilo Doval (2-0), Jake Bird and Fernando Cruz came to the rescue, even though all but Cruz were pitching for at least the second straight game. Blackburn tagged out a runner steps from home plate on a failed squeeze bunt.
With David Bednar unavailable after throwing 38 total pitches over back-to-back games, Cruz recorded the final five outs for his first save. His biggest out was inducing a fly ball to center field from slugger José Ramírez with two on and two out to end the eighth.
- CHECK OUT THE LATEST MLB STANDINGS AND YANKEES STATS
“We don’t have the big names [in the bullpen], but we’re a special group,” Cruz told The Post. “We’re hungry. We’re really united. And we’re really into taking the task. There’s something really special going on back there.”
Then Cruz struck out the side in the ninth.
“He’s saved our bacon a bunch of times this year,” Boone said. “He’s put out so many fires for us in the biggest moments of the game.”
With the score tied 2-2, the Guardians kept Tim Herrin in the game after his scoreless seventh specifically to pitch lefty-on-lefty to Chisholm, who launched a full-count pitch into the right field seats using slugger Aaron Judge’s bat.
“He’s a good pitcher and he doesn’t really miss his spots,” Chisholm said. “For him to miss in that spot, it’s like a huge sigh of relief.”
Chisholm didn’t leave the batter’s box until the ball descended 360 feet away and milked his home run trot as the boos loudened. Was he fueled by being called overrated?
“Oh yeah,” Chisholm said. “I think that’s why I overswung the at-bat before. The next at-bat I was like, ‘Keep your composure.’ I love [the chants] kind of. I feel like that was the loudest chants all day.”
Chisholm’s was the second Yankees long ball of the game.
Spencer Jones hit his first career home run in his 33rd at-bat to provide a 2-0 lead in the second inning. The No. 6 prospect in the organization also singled to continue a promising four-game stretch since his second call-up.
The Guardians tied the score at 2-2 and left the bases loaded in the third.
Chase DeLauter’s two-out RBI single ate up lightning-rod shortstop Anthony Volpe, who couldn’t keep the ball in the infield. The 96 mph smash hopped right in front of Volpe as he shifted his body to the side and wound up on his butt.
“Bullet, ’tweener,” Boone said. “With a man on second there, one you want to try and body up if you can. Tough play.”
Cole was booed after hitting Rhys Hoskins on the knuckles by coming up and in. Hoskins fell flat on his back — just six days after Hoskins homered off Cole.
Maybe Cole’s mind still was sidetracked because he was late covering first base — in shades of the 2024 World Series — after Angel Martínez hit a hard ground ball to first base that was stopped on a dive by Paul Goldschmidt. The costly delay — Cole was thinking double off the bat — resulted in a bang-bang RBI single.
The trainer visited the mound to check Cole after he slid bare hand first into the bag. No injury concern looms, and even Boone admitted the check-in was as much to let Cole catch his breath as to test his hand.
Go beyond the box score with the Bombers
Sign up for Inside the Yankees by Greg Joyce, exclusively on Sports+.
Thank you
“That’s about as deep of a jam as you can get in,” Cole said. “I guess the good part is we were able to escape with two and keep us in the game.”
