If The New York Times is to be believed, rumors of American democracy’s demise have been greatly exaggerated.
“The November election became not just a referendum on President Trump, but also a crucial test of American democracy,” Times author Emily Bazelon claimed in a post-midterm piece. “In the end, the country passed.”
It’s a jarring about-face from an outlet that, as recently as last August, claimed Donald Trump represented an existential threat to the country’s democratic norms.
“American democracy has been deteriorating with alarming velocity since President Trump’s return to the White House,” wrote Skye Perryman in a Times op-ed. “We must not be satisfied with watching the decline of American democracy from our phones.”
But apparently all it took was one election where Democrats swept several races to allay the Gray Lady’s fears of democratic desolation.
Such hypocritical analysis on the health of American democracy is nothing new. Following Trump’s initial election in 2016, Times writers described abject horror at the idea the country had elected a “candidate so manifestly unqualified for high office.”
So said Paul Krugman, who declared that while Times readers love democracy “there turn out to be a huge number of people… who don’t share at all our idea of what America is about.” Krugman took his fearmongering to truly ludicrous places, arguing Trump’s election meant America could possibly be a failed state.
By 2020, when Joe Biden had won the presidency, the Times declared American democracy had survived its “brush with death,” until 2024 when, once again, “Mr. Trump’s election pose[d] a grave threat to th[e] republic.”
It is nakedly transparent that the Times treats wins from the Democrats as American democracy’s salvation, but Republican wins as threats. Indeed, the Times spent months pontificating whether Trump would allow the midterms to happen at all. But when none of those crises came to pass, and the American people opted to hand congressional power to Team Blue, the sky stopped falling.
Democracy is saved! Please ignore the previous alarmist rhetoric. As Bazelon put it, “perhaps the rumors of democracy’s demise were premature.”
It’s deeply ironic that the Times is more obsessed with phantom threats to democracy from the Trump administration when there are actual, tangible threats to ignore the will of the people from Democratic controlled states.
Though Republicans lost big on Election Day, conservative policy won in some surprising places. Two ballot measures covering biological sex passed resoundingly in sapphire blue Washington state and Colorado.
The Washington measure will prohibit biologically male students from competing against female students and require student athletes attempting to play in female sports to verify their sex. In Colorado, voters approved a measure requiring student athletes to compete on teams that match their sex.
The people spoke, and thus the government is bound by the sacred responsibilities of American Democracy to enact the agenda, yes?
The newly elected governor in Colorado, Phil Weiser, publicly said he wants to “tweak” the ballot measures and argued the state would “have to take a look at these anti-trans measures and what adjustments are necessary and appropriate.”
Democratic lawmakers in Washington state went even further, pledging to challenge their state’s ban and saying that the fight over the voter-approved measure is “just beginning.” Those same Democrats argued the measure is unconstitutional and will support court challenges to overturn it.
This is an actual threat to democracy, where representatives tell the voting public they are wrong and attempt to subvert their will. But one doubts the Times, which breathlessly argued the end of democracy was imminent at the feet of the Trump administration, will raise an eyebrow at this blatant disregard for the desires of the voting public.
Such accusations of anti-democratic behavior are reserved only for the Times’s political enemies. Perhaps the rumors of democracy’s demise really were premature. Apparently, democracy is doing just fine, so long as The New York Times likes the results.
***
Doug Blair is press manager at Heritage Action for America.


