A Muslim senator will soon lay his hand on Thomas Jefferson’s Quran, and America will applaud a book it has never read.
Abdul El-Sayed is invoking the third president’s copy as a symbol of American openness. The gesture is not even new, since Keith Ellison did the same in 2007. It’s clever because it trades on what Westerners think they know about Jefferson and, more importantly, what they don’t know about the Quran.
Most Americans have never opened it. They know the headline version, that Islam is a religion of peace and the Quran a cousin of the Psalms, and they were taught that to doubt this is bigotry or islamophobia.
That ignorance is the soil in which Islamic claims grow best. A text people refuse to read can be made to mean anything, and every claim made in its name goes unchallenged.
So, what does the Quran say about Jews and Christians, and how should they be treated as non-Muslims?
The Quran does acknowledge that Jews and Christians received scripture, but only to tell them that they are misguided and have corrupted it. It instructs Muslims not to take Jews and Christians as allies and explicitly denies the heart of the Christian faith, insisting that Jesus was neither killed nor crucified. It then mocks the claim that Jesus is the Son of God and invokes God’s curse on those who say it. While Muslims insist they love Jesus, they have a completely different “Jesus” from the one found in the Bible.
Then comes the law (think, Sharia) that follows from that Quran. Islam’s scripture commands Muslims to fight Jews and Christians until they pay the jizya “while humiliated.” No Muslim would take these verses as symbolic or metaphorical, since Islamic history is full of atrocities committed in application of this verse. For centuries, Christians and Jews under Muslim rule paid a jizya tax that was meant to remind them of their inferior place. If Jews and Christians are considered by Muslims to be unbelievers or infidels, then their destiny is blunt: “When you meet those who disbelieve in battle, strike their necks until you have inflicted slaughter upon them, then secure the bonds of the captives.”
This is the Quran the senator-elect wants to swear on. But what about the Jefferson copy of the Quran?
Either Abdul doesn’t know this history, or he is counting on the audience not to. I don’t know which is worse.
Consider what Jefferson actually did with his Quran. In 1765, a 22-year-old law student bought George Sale’s English translation. He did not buy it out of devotion. He was a lawyer studying the legal systems of the world, as part of a comparative education in the world’s religions and laws. The book sat on his shelf for decades before it mattered.
It mattered in 1786, when Jefferson and John Adams met in London with the Muslim ambassador of Tripoli, Sidi Haji Abdrahaman Adja, to ask why his corsairs were seizing American ships and enslaving their crews. The Muslim answered that the Quran gave Muslims the right and duty to make war on nations that had not acknowledged Muhammad and to enslave the prisoners they captured.
Jefferson learned what Islam’s scripture teaches, and upon becoming president, he did not pay jizya tribute to the Muslims or accommodate them. He sent the Navy.
More revealingly, Jefferson never praised Islam as a religion, although, in his Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, he insisted that civil rights should not depend on religion and wanted the “Mahometan” (Muslims) included among those protected. Let this sink in: a US president wanted Muslims protected, while Islam’s so-called scripture insists on targeting Christians because of their religion until they are humiliated and subdued.
Jefferson saw a political and military doctrine that justified aggression against outsiders on religious grounds, and he answered it with force. That is a far cry from the sentimental symbol El-Sayed wants us to see.
There is a final irony. The copy Jefferson owned is an English translation, made by an Englishman. In Muslim understanding, a translation is not the Quran. The Quran is the Arabic text, and any other language gives only an interpretation. By the strict standard of his own tradition, the senator-elect will be swearing on a book that is not, for Muslims, the real book. Either he knows this and intends the gesture as a political prop, or he doesn’t and has chosen a symbol he doesn’t understand.
None of this seems to trouble the progressive left, which has found its new allies. On campuses, in coalitions, and in the press, Islamist causes now march alongside progressive ones, and each side finds the other useful. The partnership runs on one resource that never runs short: Western ignorance of what the “sacred” texts say and what they built.
Those texts enslaved nations for centuries. They humiliated Christians and Jews in the very lands where the Church was born. They are still taught, still memorized, and still obeyed by those who take them at their word. So let the senator-elect lay his hand on Jefferson’s book. Let the cameras flash, and let the nation applaud. Then let someone, anyone, have the courage to open the book and read it aloud.
***
A. S. Ibrahim holds two PhDs in Islamic Studies. He is the author of “Sharia Versus the U.S. Constitution: Why Americans Must Choose Freedom” and “Islam and the West.” He has also authored “Muhammad’s Military Expeditions” (Oxford, 2024), “A Concise Guide to the Life of Muhammad” (Baker Academic, 2022), “Conversion to Islam” (Oxford, 2021), “Basics of Arabic” (Zondervan, 2021), “A Concise Guide to the Quran” (Baker Academic, 2020), and “The Stated Motivations for the Early Islamic Expansion” (Peter Lang, 2018), among others. Follow him on X: @al2ostaz


