in

Grading MLB’s Biggest Offseason Deals, Including Maikel Garcia To Mariners

grading-mlb’s-biggest-offseason-deals,-including-maikel-garcia-to-mariners
Grading MLB’s Biggest Offseason Deals, Including Maikel Garcia To Mariners

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Baseball’s hot stove is warming up as teams look to upgrade their rosters before the expiration of the collective bargaining agreement on Dec. 1. 

We’re waiting to see where this offseason’s top free agents, like two-time Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal or star Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato will land. As more players come off the board, we’re grading notable deals and how they impact the teams involved.

JUMP TO: White Sox Ship Castillo | Garcia To Seattle | Twins Sign Gray | White Sox Sign May | Red Sox Sign Bauers | Braves Sign Phillips

Colorado receives: RHP Luis Castillo and RHP Davis Martin 

Chicago receives: LHP Sean Sullivan and minor-league C Douglas Veliz 

Grade for Rockies: B-

Grade for White Sox: Incomplete

Breaking Down The Deal: This one came as a surprise, considering the White Sox just added Dustin May to try to bolster a rotation that was a weak spot last season. Now they’re taking two starting pitching options away. It’s an acknowledgment of the mistake they made when they traded for Castillo at last season’s deadline, a move that seemed risky for a White Sox team that needed more reliability from its starting pitchers. At the time, Castillo had a 5.06 ERA, the lowest strikeout rate of his career, concerning underlying numbers and a contract few would have been willing to take on. The White Sox did it anyway, getting some salary relief by sending reliever Seranthony Dominguez back to Seattle along with a legitimate prospect in Boston Smith. 

Luis Castillo's short stint in Chicago didn't go as planned. (Photo by Joe Sullivan/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

Luis Castillo’s short stint in Chicago didn’t go as planned. (Photo by Joe Sullivan/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

It all ended badly, as many feared, with Castillo registering an 8.42 ERA over nine appearances in Chicago and losing his spot in the White Sox rotation. Now, to move Castillo’s $22.75 million salary, they had to include a valuable big-league starter in Martin. Getting off the Castillo contract probably deserves a C here, but for now it gets an incomplete because this grade is entirely dependent on what the White Sox do with those savings. Neither Sullivan, a left-handed pitcher who debuted last year for the Rockies, nor Veliz, a 17-year-old catcher out of Venezuela who’s more of a dart throw, are particularly highly-regarded prospects. The White Sox now must meaningfully upgrade the rotation with pieces better than Castillo and Martin. 

The Rockies were going to have their hands full convincing starting pitchers to go to Colorado on the open market, so it’s possible the additions of Castillo and Martin were better than anything they could have done in free agency. Castillo is coming off the worst season of his career and just allowed the highest pulled fly ball rate of his career — not a great sign as he heads to Coors Field! — but he is a three-time All-Star who had produced an ERA under 4.00 in seven straight seasons before his 2026 implosion. The bigger get is Martin, who had an All-Star caliber first half for the White Sox (9-4, 3.41 ERA) before free-falling in the second half (0-4, 5.12). Martin’s 45.1% hard-hit rate last year could spell trouble in Colorado, but he finished the year with a 3.95 ERA and he represents an upgrade for a Rockies pitching staff that needs all the help it can get. – Kavner

Seattle receives: 3B Maikel Garcia, RHP James McArthur and a minor league reliever 

Kansas City receives: RHP Bryce Miller, LHP Jose Ferrer and RHP Logan Evans

Grade for Mariners: A-

Grade for Royals: C

Breaking Down The Deal: For years, we have been waiting for the Mariners to trade away someone, anyone, from their gigantic reserve of pitchers to help address some of their immediate needs. Mariners president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto made it clear at November’s GM Meetings that the club’s biggest priority this offseason was to improve their defense, particularly on the left field of the infield. Garcia is one of the best defensive third basemen in the league. He had a down year offensively this past season, when he was limited to just 82 games after dealing with multiple injuries. Garcia is still just 26 years old, and in a healthy year, he should be expected to replicate his 2025 All-Star season, when he hit .286/.351/.449 (121 OPS+).

Maikel Garcia heads to Seattle. (Photo by Jay Biggerstaff/Getty Images)

Maikel Garcia heads to Seattle. (Photo by Jay Biggerstaff/Getty Images)

So, for Seattle, this trade makes sense in its efforts to win now and repeat the deep postseason run it enjoyed in 2025. The Mariners have needed an everyday bat for a while now, and their surplus of arms made this deal possible. Garcia headlines a three-player package that also includes a pair of relievers, with McArthur having some closing experience with subpar results. Even despite losing Miller to the Royals in this trade, the Mariners still have a solid rotation led by Logan Gilbert, Bryan Woo and George Kirby. Losing Ferrer hurts Seattle, but Dipoto should be able to beef up his bullpen in other ways this winter. 

As for the Royals’ end of this, I have some questions. Who’s going to play third base with Garcia out of the picture? And why trade the young franchise cornerstone Kansas City just signed to a five-year extension less than a year ago? 

If the bottom line for the Royals is that they needed pitching help, there are multiple mid-rotation starters available in free agency this offseason, and they wouldn’t even need to break the bank to shore up the rotation while also keeping Garcia. Take, for instance, free-agent right-hander Michael Soroka. The Athletic projected Soroka to land a three-year contract in the range of $54 million. Soroka is even coming off a better season than Miller, who dealt with elbow-related injuries in 2026, which led to a dip in performance and even a demotion to the bullpen in the second half of the season. Even though Kansas City did well to acquire three pitchers in one trade, it seems like the Royals could’ve addressed their lack of arms by spending some money, without trading away their third baseman of the future. — Thosar

Sonny GrayMinnesota Twins

Contract: Two years, $55 million (including an opt-out) 

Grade: B+

Breaking Down The Deal: One way to help a bullpen in need? Get a standout starter who doesn’t need much assistance in the middle innings. Gray is coming off a stellar season in Boston in which he went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA and finished fifth in American League Cy Young voting. And, as he will tell you, he was particularly good the longer a game went on. 

“I think I’m the best pitcher in the American League going through the order the third time,” Gray said while frustrated after getting pulled with two outs in the fifth inning of Boston’s Game 2 wild-card loss to the Yankees. “I think that’s a fact.” 

Sonny Gray heads back to the Twin Cities. (Photo by Caleb Bowlin/Getty Images)

Sonny Gray heads back to the Twin Cities. (Photo by Caleb Bowlin/Getty Images)

Indeed, Gray was exceptional last season against opponents the third time through the order, holding them to a .180/.235/.280 slash line in those situations. That ability should be especially helpful to the Twins, who have yet to address a bullpen that ranked in the bottom five in MLB in ERA and WHIP. 

While there is risk in giving multiple years to a 37-year-old — especially one whose strikeout rate has dipped from 30.3% in 2024 to 26.7% in 2025 and 21.8% in 2026 — this signing could help turn the Twins’ rotation into a real strength if Pablo López returns from Tommy John surgery looking like himself again. It’s also a positive sign that the Twins, after years of cutting payroll, will take necessary steps to try to contend in a winnable division. 

Gray, who was an All-Star with the Twins in 2023, has already demonstrated his ability to succeed in Minnesota, and his extensive pitch mix could allow him to continue succeeding deep into his 30s despite the red flags with his whiff rate. He has also been a model of reliability, having thrown more than 160 innings each of the past four seasons. The Twins still need to add relief help, but bringing back catcher Ryan Jeffers and adding Gray is a strong start to free agency. – Kavner

Dustin MayChicago White Sox

Contract: Three years, $52.5 million 

Grade: C+

Breaking Down This Deal: The White Sox needed to stabilize their rotation this winter after getting the fewest innings from their starting pitchers of any team in MLB. May provides depth to the group as a high-upside mid-rotation arm, though his injury history and inconsistencies on the mound present risk for a team that needs innings and reliability. May’s 145 innings last season between the Cardinals and Brewers represented a career high. 

Dustin May was a midseason pick for the Brewers on their way to the World Series. (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)

Dustin May was a midseason pick for the Brewers on their way to the World Series. (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)

He demonstrated his high ceiling with a complete-game shutout against the Padres on June 15, and the eventual World Series champions thought highly enough of May’s tools to make him their main pitching addition at the deadline after he posted a 4.38 ERA in 22 starts in St. Louis. But his numbers dipped in the second half in Milwaukee. May had a 5.65 ERA in 10 regular-season starts with the Brewers and a 5.73 ERA in five playoff appearances. 

His fastball velocity (96.9 mph), good extension off the mound using his 6-foot-6-inch frame and better-than-average strikeout rate, walk rate and overall stuff give reason to believe the 29-year-old’s best could still be ahead. But this was a rather significant commitment given his actual performance to this point, and I expected the White Sox to be shopping a tier above on the starting pitching market to address their biggest need. Perhaps that still happens. – Kavner

Jake BauersBoston Red Sox

Contract: Four years, $58 million

Grade: B

Breaking Down This Deal: Never give up, kids. A couple years ago, Bauers was considering retirement. Now look at him. Of the eight players given the one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer, Bauers seemed perhaps the likeliest candidate to accept. After all, if he produced at the same level again next season, that would make more teams willing to believe his breakout and allow him to cash in again in 2028. Instead, the Red Sox were willing to pounce in their search for power, and the 31-year-old slugger opted for the long-term security of a four-year deal. Boston is banking on Bauers building off his career year in Milwaukee, a season in which he ranked seventh in MLB in wRC+ and tied for 10th in OPS and came up clutch in October. 

Jake Bauers' postseason performances boosted his free agent stock. (Katelyn Mulcahy/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

Jake Bauers’ postseason performances boosted his free agent stock. (Katelyn Mulcahy/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

There is obvious risk involved. Entering 2026, the journeyman had a career .672 OPS and had never hit more than 12 home runs in a season. Bauers will cost the Red Sox their second and fifth-highest draft selections, and the fit is imperfect. Boston’s best hitter this year was its first baseman, Willson Contreras. Those two now figure to split first base and DH duties, leaving even fewer at-bats available for the surplus of Red Sox outfielders, which might necessitate a trade. 

But the Red Sox, who finished 26th in home runs and 21st in walks, saw an opportunity to acquire a talent who could help in both areas. The underlying numbers suggest Bauers’ breakout was real, and if he plays the way he did last year for the next four seasons, his $14.5 million average annual salary will look like a steal. — Kavner

Evan PhillipsAtlanta Braves

Contract: Three years, $35 million 

Grade: B-

Breaking Down This Deal: While the team’s more glaring need is starting pitching, the Braves had some work to do if they wanted to maintain one of the best bullpens in the sport with closer Raisel Iglesias reaching free agency. The addition of Phillips, who was one of MLB’s best relievers when healthy over the last six years with the Dodgers, should help. Signing him now also provides the Braves some flexibility as the offseason continues. They could still sign another closer and have Phillips, Robert Suarez or Dylan Lee pitching high-leverage innings, or they could roll with any of those three for the ninth inning while turning their attention to their more glaring needs (starting pitching, shortstop). It also gives them more freedom to decide the role they want for versatile 21-year-old Didier Fuentes. 

A high-leverage arm is heading to Atlanta. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/Getty Images)

A high-leverage arm is heading to Atlanta. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/Getty Images)

For Phillips, the deal marks a return to where it all began. The 32-year-old was drafted by the Braves in 2015 and debuted with the team in 2018 before being traded to Baltimore. He was released in 2021, signed a minor-league deal with the Rays, got designated for assignment and was claimed by the Dodgers, where he turned his career around, producing a 2.36 ERA with 254 strikeouts and 46 saves in 221 innings over the last six seasons. 

Phillips returned from Tommy John surgery last season and averaged the highest four-seam velocity of his career. He was also barreled more than ever before — which, in tandem with the highest fly-ball rate and lowest ground-ball rate of his career, led to him surrendering five home runs in 26 innings — but he struck out 33 batters with just six walks, and his stuff looked better as the year progressed. Over the last two months of the season, Phillips had a 2.41 ERA with 24 strikeouts and four walks in 18.2 innings. He then made five scoreless appearances in the postseason. It’s an expensive price for a reliever who might not be their closer and a pitcher who has thrown just 86.1 regular-season innings over the last three seasons. But as long as he is healthy, the addition of Phillips should keep Atlanta’s bullpen a strength. — Kavner

Major League BaseballMLB Related Stories

Leave a Reply

calvinist-weatherman-forecasts-another-beautiful-week-of-whatever-god-wills

Calvinist Weatherman Forecasts Another Beautiful Week of Whatever God Wills

jets-coach-aaron-glenn-gives-geno-smith-injury-update-for-chargers-clash

Jets Coach Aaron Glenn Gives Geno Smith Injury Update For Chargers Clash