in

Islanders look far from their best in overtime loss to Jets that slipped from their grasp

islanders-look-far-from-their-best-in-overtime-loss-to-jets-that-slipped-from-their-grasp
Islanders look far from their best in overtime loss to Jets that slipped from their grasp

See more of our coverage in your search results.

WINNIPEG, Manitoba — Winning usually determines what most people see in a Rorschach test of a performance like what the Islanders put forward Thursday night. Plus, the loser point the NHL hands out after overtime defeats does not lend itself to clarity. 

On a night like this, though, it felt sort of fitting. 

They were not terribly outplayed by the Jets, but the game the Islanders put forward at Canada Life Centre was far from their best, even as they gave themselves a chance to win. They took — then handed back — three one-goal leads before ultimately losing 4-3 on Josh Morrissey’s winner in the extra period. That is what you might call a missed opportunity. 

New York Islanders players Adam Pelech, Jean-Gabriel Pageau, Casey Cizikas, Anthony Duclair, and Tony DeAngelo celebrate a goal.

Adam Pelech, Jean-Gabriel Pageau, Casey Cizikas, Anthony Duclair and Tony DeAngelo celebrate a goal in Winnipeg on Nov. 19, 2026. NHLI via Getty Images

Indeed, there will be plenty for coach Pete DeBoer to dissect after a halting performance up and down a lineup that seemed to operate at 70 percent of its capacity throughout. 

The Jets didn’t look so great either, making for a game that was suspenseful, but in which the mistakes felt more decisive than anything else. The 3-3 tie that carried into the third period came with both teams searching for their best. 

And, in the last 20 minutes, both teams got closer to it than the first 40. The pace was better. Semyon Varlamov made great saves on Braydon Yager and Kyle Connor. Matias Maccelli and Victor Eklund, who had both struggled through the first two periods, raised their respective levels. 

They could not, however, get one past Nico Daws in the lowest-event period of the three. 

Morrissey made them pay with a wrister that hit Varlamov’s glove before it landed in the back of the net. 

Making matters worse was that the Islanders played the third period without Ryan Pulock, who was helped down the tunnel by trainers at the end of the second, just three games into his return from a shoulder issue. 

Winnipeg Jets' Cole Perfetti (91) celebrates his goal against New York Islanders goaltender Semyon Varlamov.

Winnipeg Jets’ Cole Perfetti (91) celebrates his goal against New York Islanders goaltender Semyon Varlamov in Winnipeg, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. John Woods/The Canadian Press via AP

The Islanders, who reintegrated Jean-Gabriel Pageau into the lineup between Casey Cizikas and Anthony Duclair on an overpowered fourth line, had struck first when Cizikas fed Duclair just 2:35 into the match. The game’s theme revealed itself quickly, though, when Morgan Barron tied it at 1-1 just 31 seconds later off a deflection from Dylan Samberg’s point shot. 

Daws and Samberg were culpable for the next two Islanders goals, with the goaltender and defenseman both committing heinous turnovers deep in their own end that were promptly taken advantage of by Emil Heineman and Kyle Palmieri. 

The Jets made sure the Islanders never got too comfortable, though. Kyle Connor tied it at 2-2 with a quick shot after Pageau lost a board battle to Mark Scheifele; Cole Perfetti made it 3-3 by poking the puck past Varlamov on a netfront scramble at the tail end of a Winnipeg power play 12:09 into the second. 

New York Islanders' Tony DeAngelo plays the puck as Winnipeg Jets' Dawson Mercer gives chase.

New York Islanders’ Tony DeAngelo plays the puck as Winnipeg Jets’ Dawson Mercer gives chase on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, in Winnipeg, Manitoba. NHLI via Getty Images

Despite the added depth to the Islanders lineup with Pageau back, there was a general lack of oomph to their game. Passes were crisp but inaccurate; decision-making was suspect at times; their battle level was fine, but the Islanders won fewer of them than normal. 

Nights like these bring to mind a key distinction. 

The Islanders gave themselves a chance to win. They did not give themselves the best chance to win.

Leave a Reply

brock-purdy’s-mvp-chances-could-disappear-sooner-than-you-think

Brock Purdy’s MVP chances could disappear sooner than you think

mets-sign-southpaw-darwinzon-hernandez-to-three-year-deal-after-stint-in-japan

Mets sign southpaw Darwinzon Hernandez to three-year deal after stint in Japan